The reason you should negotiate the process first
The rules of the negotiation are themselves negotiable, and whoever sets them first controls the range of outcomes before any substance is discussed.
Filed by The Archivist 2 min read
Intuition test — answer before you read on
Why should the process of a negotiation be negotiated before the substance?
Correct answer: A
Raiffa showed that issue sequencing determines which trades are possible. Fisher, Ury and Patton stress negotiating criteria before positions. The process is not logistics; it is the frame within which all subsequent moves are made.
Before the price is discussed, someone decides the order of agenda items, the duration of each session, who speaks first and whether proposals are written or verbal. These decisions are made quickly and usually by the party who suggests them. They are not treated as negotiation, which is why they are so powerful.
What everyone sees
Process decisions look like logistics — administrative setup that precedes the real discussion. The possibility that the process is itself a substantive concession, and that the person who designs it has already shaped the outcome, is not how agendas are discussed.
What is actually happening
Fisher, Ury and Patton described the importance of separating people from the problem and of negotiating criteria before positions. Lax and Sebenius extended this to the structure of the negotiation itself, arguing that sequencing, issue selection and the design of the agenda are moves with substantive consequences. Raiffa showed that the order in which issues are addressed changes which trades are possible, because some trades require issues to be bundled and bundling requires them to appear on the table at the same time.
Why it stays hidden
The power hides because process decisions are made under the guise of efficiency. “Let’s start with the easy items” sounds helpful, but it may mean that the difficult items arrive when time pressure is highest and concession is cheapest. The party that suggests the process is not seen as making a move; they are seen as being organised, which is a reputation benefit on top of the structural advantage.
The agenda is the first deal. Whoever sets the order, the format and the clock has already made the most important concessions invisible.
The agenda is the first deal. Whoever sets the order, the format and the clock has already made the most important concessions invisible.
Collect this card
The agenda is the first deal. Whoever sets the order, the format and the clock has already made the most important concessions invisible.
0 / 10,000 collected
Sources & further reading 3
- Fisher, Ury & Patton, "Getting to Yes", 1981
- Lax & Sebenius, "The Manager as Negotiator", 1986
- Raiffa, "The Art and Science of Negotiation", 1982
Cross-references
Related files
Filed near this one in the index.
-
Hidden Mechanics Entry #0007
Why aeroplane windows have a tiny hole
There are three panes in that window and a deliberate hole in the middle one. It decides which pane is allowed to break.
MasterThe hidden part #0007The hole chooses the victim. It hands the entire cabin pressure load to the outer pane.
Mechanics Open file -
No visual on filePlatform Mechanics Entry #0285
The reason switching costs are designed, not incidental
Importing data is easy and exporting it is hard. The asymmetry is not an engineering oversight. It is the business model, and the difficulty is the product.
MasterThe hidden part #0285The path in is lit because it serves the platform. The path out is dark because it serves the user. The two interests diverge, and the architecture follows the interest it was built to serve.
Platforms Open file -
No visual on filePersuasion Systems Entry #0260
The reason a concession invites a concession
Movement in one direction creates pressure to move in return. The obligation is not in the terms but in the norm that governs the exchange.
MasterThe hidden part #0260A concession is not just an offer. It is a move that transfers an obligation. The obligation is paid back in kind.
Persuasion Open file -
No visual on fileHabit Loops Entry #0310
The reason morning habits stick better than evening ones
The morning slot faces less competition. By evening the day has introduced alternatives, interruptions and a depleted capacity to override them.
MasterThe hidden part #0310The morning slot is not filled by discipline. It is defended by emptiness — the absence of alternatives that have not yet arrived.
Habit Open file
Annotations are reserved for archive members.
Sign in to annotate